Consistent navigation for BBC apps

I led the Consistent Navigation project within the BBC App Design System team. The challenge was to unify navigation across six flagship apps (12 inc. iOS and Android), balancing native patterns, accessibility, and brand needs.

Through stakeholder alignment, accessibility testing, and engineering collaboration, I delivered a flexible navigation framework with shared Figma components, clear documentation, and cross-team adoption plans. This work improved consistency, reduced duplication, and set the foundation for an integrated BBC app experience.

Team
App Design System

Role
Senior UX Designer

The Challenge

Navigation was fragmented:

  • Some apps used coloured headers, others a mix of bottom nav or side menus.

  • Branding sometimes clashed with accessibility (e.g. Sport’s yellow header failed WCAG).

  • Engineering teams had created custom solutions, making consistency costly.

This was not only inconsistent for audiences but also slowed down design and delivery. To meet the OKR of rolling out ADS across all app teams, we needed a consistent navigation framework that balanced:

  • Native patterns – aligned with iOS/Android guidance.

  • Accessibility – WCAG compliance and inclusive experiences.

  • Brand expression – retaining the distinctiveness of BBC Sport, News, and others.

Research and Discovery

  • Native guidance: Reviewed Apple HIG and Google Material 3 recommendations, noting that both had moved away from coloured headers.

  • Accessibility input: Worked with BBC’s accessibility team, who flagged reputational risks of releasing non-compliant designs.

  • Engineering impact: Paired with iOS and Android engineers to test feasibility, uncovering where custom overrides caused breakage.

  • Brand alignment: Engaged with brand principals to ensure BBC values were represented while advocating for more digitally-appropriate brand adaptations.

Exploration & Trade-offs

I inherited an initial proposal but identified flaws - particularly accessibility failures in Sport’s navigation. I revisited the problem from first principles.

Options explored included:

  • Removing coloured headers entirely → aligned with native, but risked losing key brand recognition.

  • Retaining coloured headers → preserved brand, but introduced accessibility failures, code complexity, and loss of native behaviours.

  • Hybrid approach → allow flexibility for Sport/News branding while keeping navigation consistent elsewhere.

I facilitated discussions with brand, accessibility, and engineering, presenting the real-world consequences of coloured headers (loss of scroll behaviour, broken large headers, additional dev effort).

Design & Delivery

  • Decision-making: Brought stakeholders along the journey through design reviews, workshops, and working group updates.

  • Final proposal: Recommended a flexible system - default to white navigation for consistency, but allow Sport and News to retain brand headers in the short term.

  • Documentation: Created detailed Figma components (iOS & Android), with scroll states, accessibility considerations, and clear rationale.

  • Engineering alignment: Paired with engineers to implement in sample apps, ensuring patterns were feasible and scalable.

  • Bottom nav “side quest”: Discovered Apple’s native components didn’t fully meet WCAG. Partnered with accessibility specialists and escalated feedback to Apple. Outcome: adopted iOS native colours as acceptable, simplifying the system while maintaining inclusivity.

Challenges and compromises

  1. Sport brand colour: Accessibility failures in light mode made the yellow header problematic.

  2. Stakeholder pushback: News team resisted losing their red header for editorial consistency with web.

    Decision: Flex the system to allow limited use of coloured headers where essential, while aligning the rest of the suite to native-first, accessible navigation.

Outcomes & Impact

  • Consistency: 5 of 6 apps scheduled to adopt the new navigation.

  • Efficiency: Shared Figma libraries reduced duplicate design effort across teams.

  • Accessibility: Documented guidance ensures WCAG compliance and clarity for product teams.

  • Culture shift: Introduced fortnightly working groups and open Slack channels, improving cross-team collaboration and buy-in.

  • Scalability: Established a decision log and documentation practice that helps navigate conflicting feedback across 12 product/engineering teams.

Reflection

  1. Keep decision logs: Essential when managing multiple stakeholders with conflicting priorities.

  2. Be precise in feedback requests: Helped reduce unproductive debates.

  3. Challenge restrictive brands: Worked with Sport brand leads to advocate for more digitally-appropriate design standards.

  4. Accept imperfection: In a design system spanning six products, there won’t always be a perfect solution - but transparency and compromise keep momentum.

Previous
Previous

BBC Vertical Video

Next
Next

BBC Sounds In Car